A Look at Blocking Twitch Ads with Tampermonkey: Is it Worth It?

I recently stumbled upon an interesting discussion about blocking Twitch ads. The proposed solution involves using Tampermonkey, a browser extension, to inject a custom script that effectively eliminates ads on the platform. This got me thinking about the pros and cons of such an approach, especially in the context of mobile devices.

Let’s delve into the details and explore whether this Tampermonkey method is a practical solution for achieving an ad-free Twitch experience, and how it compares to other ad-blocking strategies we typically recommend.

Understanding the Tampermonkey Approach

The core idea behind this method is to use Tampermonkey, a popular userscript manager available for various browsers, including Chrome. Tampermonkey allows you to run custom JavaScript code on specific websites, effectively modifying their behavior. In this case, the script is designed to detect and block ads on Twitch.

The process, as described, involves:

1. Installing Tampermonkey in Chrome.
2. Creating a new script within Tampermonkey.
3. Copying and pasting the provided JavaScript code into the script editor.
4. Saving the script, which then automatically runs whenever you visit Twitch.

While the steps seem straightforward, let's break down the implications and potential drawbacks of this method.

Advantages of the Tampermonkey Method

Fine-Grained Control

One of the biggest advantages of using Tampermonkey is the level of control it offers. Unlike some broad-spectrum ad blockers, this method allows for targeted ad blocking specifically on Twitch. This can be beneficial if you want to support other websites by allowing ads to display, while still enjoying an ad-free experience on Twitch.

Circumventing Ad Blocker Detection

Twitch, like many other platforms, actively tries to detect and block ad blockers. A custom script, if well-maintained, can potentially circumvent these detection mechanisms more effectively than generic ad-blocking extensions. This is because the script can be tailored to the specific anti-ad-blocking techniques employed by Twitch.

Potential for Customization

If you have some JavaScript knowledge, you can further customize the script to suit your specific needs. For example, you might want to adjust the script to skip certain types of ads or to handle specific edge cases that are not covered by the original script.

Disadvantages and Considerations

Browser-Specific

This method is inherently browser-specific. It relies on Tampermonkey, which is primarily a desktop browser extension. This means it won't work on native mobile apps for Twitch, limiting its usefulness if you primarily watch Twitch on your phone or tablet.

Maintenance and Updates

The effectiveness of the script depends on its maintenance. Twitch can change its ad delivery mechanisms at any time, which could render the script ineffective. This means you'll need to rely on the script author (or your own coding skills) to keep the script updated to maintain ad-blocking functionality. This contrasts with DNS-based solutions that are often updated automatically.

Security Risks

Running custom scripts from unknown sources always carries a security risk. While the provided script might be safe, it's essential to carefully review the code before installing it. Malicious scripts could potentially compromise your browser security or even steal personal information. It's always best to obtain scripts from trusted sources and understand what the code is doing before running it.

Resource Intensive

Tampermonkey and the associated scripts can consume browser resources, potentially slowing down your browsing experience, especially on older or less powerful devices. This is a trade-off to consider, especially if you're already running multiple browser extensions.

Limited Scope

This specific solution is tailored to Twitch ads. It won't block ads on other websites or within other apps. If you're looking for a comprehensive ad-blocking solution, you'll need to combine this method with other ad-blocking techniques.

How Does This Compare to Our Recommended Solutions?

At AdBlock for Mobile, we generally recommend DNS-based ad blocking for its system-wide protection and ease of use. Let's compare the Tampermonkey method to our preferred approach.

DNS-Based Blocking vs. Tampermonkey

DNS-based blocking works at the network level, filtering out ad requests before they even reach your device. This provides comprehensive protection across all apps and browsers, including the Twitch app. It's also relatively easy to set up and maintain, requiring minimal configuration.

Tampermonkey, on the other hand, is a browser-specific solution that requires manual installation and maintenance. While it offers more granular control, it's also more complex to set up and potentially less reliable due to the need for constant updates.

Here's a quick comparison table:

| Feature | DNS-Based Blocking | Tampermonkey | | ------------------ | ------------------ | --------------------- | | Scope | System-wide | Browser-specific | | Setup | Easy | More complex | | Maintenance | Minimal | Requires updates | | Customization | Limited | High | | Security | Generally safer | Potential risks | | Mobile App Support | Yes | No |

Browser Extensions

Browser extensions offer a middle ground. They are easier to install than Tampermonkey scripts, but are still limited to the browser. They also require updates and can sometimes be bypassed by websites.

VPN-Based Ad Blocking

VPN-based ad blocking, like AdGuard Pro, offers system-wide protection similar to DNS-based blocking, but it routes all your traffic through a VPN server. This can impact your internet speed and battery life. It's also a more expensive solution.

Is the Tampermonkey Method Right for You?

The decision of whether to use the Tampermonkey method depends on your specific needs and technical expertise.

Consider this method if:

• You primarily watch Twitch on a desktop browser.
• You want fine-grained control over ad blocking on Twitch.
• You're comfortable with installing and maintaining browser extensions.
• You understand the security risks associated with running custom scripts.

Avoid this method if:

• You primarily watch Twitch on a mobile app.
• You prefer a simpler, more automated solution.
• You're not comfortable with installing browser extensions or running custom scripts.
• You prioritize security and ease of maintenance.

Alternatives to Tampermonkey for Blocking Twitch Ads

If the Tampermonkey method doesn't seem like the right fit, here are some alternative approaches to consider:

DNS-Based Ad Blocking

As mentioned earlier, DNS-based ad blocking is our preferred method for mobile ad blocking. Services like NextDNS and AdGuard DNS can block ads on Twitch, although their effectiveness may vary depending on Twitch's ad delivery mechanisms. This method works on both desktop and mobile devices.

Browser Extensions (Desktop)

For desktop users, popular ad-blocking extensions like uBlock Origin and AdGuard AdBlocker can effectively block ads on Twitch within the browser. These extensions are generally easier to install and use than Tampermonkey scripts, but they may still require occasional updates to maintain their effectiveness.

Twitch Turbo (Paid Subscription)

Twitch offers a paid subscription service called Twitch Turbo, which removes ads from the platform. This is the most straightforward and reliable way to enjoy an ad-free Twitch experience, but it comes at a monthly cost.

Third-Party Twitch Apps

Some third-party Twitch apps offer built-in ad-blocking features. However, these apps may not be officially supported by Twitch, and their long-term viability is uncertain.

Considerations for Mobile Users

For mobile users, the options for blocking Twitch ads are more limited. The Tampermonkey method is not applicable to native mobile apps. DNS-based ad blocking is generally the most effective solution for blocking ads on mobile devices, but it may not be able to block all Twitch ads.

Some users have reported success using VPN-based ad blockers to block Twitch ads on mobile, but this approach can impact battery life and internet speed.

Final Thoughts on Blocking Twitch Ads

While the Tampermonkey method offers a potentially effective way to block Twitch ads on desktop browsers, it's not without its drawbacks. It requires technical expertise, manual maintenance, and carries potential security risks. For most users, DNS-based ad blocking or a paid Twitch Turbo subscription may be a more practical and reliable solution.

Ultimately, the best approach depends on your specific needs, technical skills, and willingness to trade off convenience for control. If you're comfortable with the technical aspects, the Tampermonkey method can be a viable option. However, if you prefer a simpler, more automated solution, DNS-based ad blocking is a great starting point.

Remember to always prioritize your security and privacy when choosing an ad-blocking solution. Carefully review the code of any custom scripts before running them, and only install extensions from trusted sources.

And as always, consider supporting the content creators you enjoy by disabling ad blockers on their channels or subscribing to their content. They rely on ad revenue and subscriptions to continue creating the content you love.